
I was listening to "Gutter" recently and the line "see the carvings on their arms" made me feel weird. It's the only song I've ever heard that mentions self-harm (the cutting form specifically) with the intention to de-stigmatise it and to make people feel empathy for those do it. Usually songs that mention cutting are like "I wanna slit my wrists and play in it cuz I'm into that" (BMTH reference. I love that song and that band sm) or "I'll cut myself because I'm disgusting and that's what disgusting people do and also my parents don't listen to me". So it's... nice? in a way, to hear that sort of change happening.
But I think this is a theme with Melanie's art. In a similar way to how Marilyn Manson was the Antichrist Superstar, the spokesperson of the anti-people who was brave enough to sing about all the evilness of humanity, Melanie wants to be the spokesperson for insecure, lonely, traumatised, vulnerable people. But while Manson operated from anger and insecurity and physically tried to make himself seem more emotionally intense than he was in order to elicit the intended audience response, Melanie operates from a desire to be connected spiritually to everyone on earth—it's not necessarily acting based on the anger she feels for these problems, but it's as if she will have these huge emotions anyway, so she found it better to use them for a good cause. Thinking about it this way, listening to this new album just seems like a personal passion project to feed off of as many insecurities as possible so she can say, once again, "I understand you, you're perfect the way you are, I feel the same way, do you see how I can save you from your loneliness?" but has forced herself to disguise it as a social political thing so that people don't view it as out-of-touch or narcissistic.
Another thing I think is that Hades is really good as far as concept albums go. It takes the dystopia theme and explores many different elements of what makes this world dystopian. Through this mechanical type of pop/grunge style, she tackles the ever-growing swarm of manipulative men, corrupt governments, selfish billionaires, how the beauty standard has changed from just "don't be ugly" to basically being a perfect mannequin, and how poor, marginalised communities don't just get swept under the rug, but actively demonised. These are all symptoms of a dystopian world and I can really feel all of the songs on the album because she has basically sucked up all the negative energy of these song's topics so she can feel them and portray them correctly. The only thing I think she doesn't do so well is marketing. She introduced this album with a new character, Circle, and I don't think I'm exaggerating when I say that 99% of her fans were expecting this album to revolve around Circle, in a similar way to how Cry Baby got songs about her and her life. It was a similar thing with Portals and K-12. Her characters are introduced along with a theme—in fact, I think that the characters are the introduction of the theme—but are never brought up again when the album actually comes out. The songs have nothing to do with the character and are all Melanie's thoughts/feelings, and sometimes they don't even really fit with the advertised theme of the album.
I'm just not sure why she would advertise her music this way. I understand that Cry Baby was probably the most "Melanie" type character, so maybe she found it much easier to sing from her perspective, and that the Portals spirit was straying a bit, so we got a few songs that were slightly out of place. But Circle is not Melanie. Circle is the anti-Melanie. Going back to the Manson comparison—he embraced his status as becoming anti-himself, in order to please the people and call out these issues. In fact, a big thing with Manson's anti-character was that he realised what a hypocrite he'd be if he said he hated the world but didn't hate himself, so he included himself when singing about how the world is filled with shitty people. But Melanie has no purpose to being anti-herself because she wants to pour her emotions and empathy onto everybody and believe that she is a saviour for all those vulnerable people out there. She wants people to love her, not Circle, so she basically just introduced Circle to represent who she was singing for, as well as to introduce what she was singing against. So I just think that this album is inherently contradictory, and while I understand that her motive must be to shed light on taboo topics, I don't believe it was advertised very accurately and this is where a lot of Hades' backlash is not exactly warranted but understandable.
And that's all I really have to say. I am a fan of Melanie's music. I love it. I am just neutral towards Melanie herself.

















